Pitter Patter

As I was driving to work this morning I seriously contemplated which man over 40 I find most attractive.
I am meeting someone new.

I have a wicked idea for a gag. Now I just need to find someone who is willing to lend me their infant.
Open to suggestions.

edit: I chose Robert Redford.
Sam Waterston was a runner-up, though I didn't mention him.
He was my heart's choice.